Miscarriage and late term pregnancy loss are taboo subjects, especially in American society. This is a saddening fact considering 15 % of women experience a miscarriage at least once in their life, and nearly one in 200 pregnancies end in stillbirth each year. Women that experience these losses often find themselves in an odd place. They are yearning to discuss their loss, mourn the life of their child with those they love. Yet the people they love do not know how to console them. I have four friends who have experienced miscarriages that I know of, and my own mother experience three of them herself. I have two friends that experienced stillbirths. Each time I was afraid of what to say. I did not want to say the wrong thing, because I did not want to make their pain worse. The best I could do is offer to be there for them, and to understand if they could not be around my own children for the time being. I have seen shows mention miscarriage, but never delve deeply into the emotions involved in losing a child during pregnancy. So when Lifetime showed the commercial for their new movie,
Return to Zero, I was intrigued. I wanted to watch it to see how they would show the emotional roller coaster that both the wife and husband experienced. So despite my pregnancy hormones that would guarantee a river of tears, I sat down to watch it Saturday night.
The movie started out with a gender reveal party thrown by the wife's mother and her friends. The wife's best friend was also pregnant and I knew this would play a big part in the movie. They cut into a gender reveal cake to discover they were having a boy, which made the husband very happy. Shortly after the party, the friend was visiting the wife. The wife began to have pains, and the friend thought she might be going into labor. The friend left to go home, and the wife told her husband that she had spotted blood when she went to the bathroom. She called her doctor and he told her it was probably her mucus plug which meant the baby would be coming soon. Honestly, I was shocked to hear a movie mention the mucus plug in a non joking manor. I loved it! Her doctor asked her to come in the next morning so he could check her over and see how she was progressing. In the morning, the husband had to go to a very important business meeting. He asked her if she needed him to go, which she didn't want to make him miss the meeting even though she still had slight fears. He went to work and she went to her doctor appointment. How many times does this happen? I for one have gone to appointments alone when my husband has had to work. We think nothing of it. At the appointment the nurse is talking to her about being excited to have him in her arms soon. The nurse goes to listen for the heartbeat and can't find it. She says the machine must be broken so she leaves the room to get another one. I could see the wife beginning to be afraid, but ignoring that fear as well. The nurse comes back and tries to find the heartbeat again. Once more she can't find the heartbeat. She leaves the room to get the doctor, and at this point the wife is afraid. The doctor brings in an ultrasound machine and says he's just going to take a look. He begins to look at the baby and at first the wife is relieved. Then the doctor has to gently inform her that there is no heartbeat. He tells her that her baby has died. At first the wife is in denial, asking him to look again. He has to keep telling her that her baby has died. She begins to break down and he asks if anyone drove her. He tells her to call her husband. This was the most realistic response they could have done. Her denial and break down felt real, as if all of her hopes of the future were being ripped away from her. The husband comes to the office and the doctor has them sit down with a social worker. She asks them if they had picked out a name. They tell her that they had wanted to name him Arthur. She begins to go over their options regarding birth, c-section or natural delivery. They husband tells them to just cut it out. The wife doesn't say anything to this, but you can tell his words bother her. He is clearly distraught as well, but can't handle it. The doctor tells them to sleep on it, to rest a day and come back the next morning for the induction. He suggests holding the baby afterwards and taking photos to remember him by.
The next day they go to the hospital for the induction, but at this point they do not show the delivery or the couple holding Arthur. Soon after, they hold a memorial service for Arthur. A few people talk about how Arthur was loved and they release balloons in his memory. While they are grieving, the wife empties the nursery closet and packs away the clothes. She comes across a gift that they hadn't opened yet and she throws it away outside. The husband begins building a boat and throws himself into the project. They both have difficulty opening up about their son. She blames her own body and calls her uterus a deadly weapon. He has been drinking more and cleans the beer bottles up in the garage. He goes to throw them away and finds the gift she had thrown out. He puts it back in the nursery closet. One night at dinner he gives her a gift that he had bought as a birth present like they had discussed. He didn't see why he shouldn't give it to her. She tells him the day of the birth was the worst day of their lives. They go to another doctor and discuss Arthur with her. The autopsy showed that Arthur had a cyst in his liver that had metastasized and caused his liver to burst. The husband begins questioning why no one picked up on that, why no one caught it before it was too late. He wants to blame anyone, the doctors even. He just wants someone to blame. I can understand this, when something unexpected like this happens you need someone to blame in order to help cope with the loss. That's just how our grief works. Soon after the doctor visit, the wife finds the baby gift in the closet. She goes with her friend to the store it was purchased from. She asks if they can return it and the sales associate asks for the gift receipt. It has been more than sixty days so they can't take it back. This causes the wife's grief to overwhelm her. She becomes angry and smashes the gift on the floor. Honestly I would have too. As she told the associate, there's a damn good reason she didn't make it back within sixty days.
The husband's female co-worker says he needs to go out for drinks. So she takes him to a bar where she tries to get his mind off of the baby. Honestly at this point, I knew where this was going later on. That night he tries to initiate sex with his wife, but she isn't interested. Yes, I definitely knew where this going sadly. The wife goes to her friend's baby shower. A woman comes up to her and asks how the baby is doing. Obviously this poor woman has no idea what had happened. Then the wife goes to place her gift on a table and say hello to friends. They all move away from her and she says she forgot she was contagious. While talking to her friend, a mutual friend comes up to her to express how sorry she is for her loss. She tells the wife she was moved to come talk to her. The woman begins talking about God's will and how impossible it is to understand it. She tells her that his plan is perfect in every single way. This causes the wife to lose her patience. She goes off on the woman about how it must be God's plan for her suffer. She was obviously upset by what the woman said, and I cringed when the woman first said what she had. The wife turns to her friend and says she shouldn't have come. She leaves the baby shower, and I do not blame her. I have never understood telling a grieving parent that everything happens for a reason, or that it is in God's plan. Like the wife said in the movie, it has made her question her faith. While in the end it may strengthen her faith later on, or change it completely, that is her journey to make. In her grief those comments made by a well meaning friend struck her in a painful way. It just made her loss worse to her, as if she should feel bad for being angry with the universe that her child died. Another instance of someone's words inflicting more pain onto her occurs when she decides to return to work. She is a psychologist and one of her patients notes she isn't herself. She refers to the loss as a miscarriage and mentions she had one of those once. She then says not to worry, you get over it in time.
The wife visits with her physician again for a check up. The doctor asks her if she's been getting out of the house and the wife tells her she has. She talks about how people don't seem to know how to talk to her. The doctor says it is hard on them as well. The wife begins telling the doctor she doubts anyone gets what is like for her, especially the doctor. The doctor then confides in her that when she was in med school, she too had a stillborn. She has since had daughters, but the pain of losing her son is still there. She tells the wife because of what she went through, what her son has taught her, she will appreciate a child like few others can. She tells her that she will always be Arthur's mom and to be proud of that because he is.
Remember that female coworker taking the husband out for drinks? Well they're at work late one night, drinking of course, and they have an affair. Sadly I called it. Not because that's what all men do when experiencing loss like this, but because Lifetime set it up that way. Still it shocked me to see it in a way. I know everyone responds to grief differently, but I had hoped he would have been drawn closer to his wife. After his affair, they have family over for Thanksgiving. During the meal the husband's father makes a toast to life and talks about family. The wife is obviously bothered by his speech considering what they've gone through this past year. She then makes a speech about life and how death is right under the surface. So she toasts death and her husband clinks glasses with her. Love it. That part honestly made me laugh. I got a glimpse of the wife being a smart ass much like myself in the moment. So the husband suggests they boycott Christmas. They go to Vegas and party it up. Which of course leads to a hot drunken sex scene against the hotel window. In that moment I turned to my husband and bet him that she gets pregnant. He bet I was wrong. After Vegas I had hoped his affair would be done with. I was wrong. He doesn't come home one night and doesn't answer his phone. When he does walk in she says she's glad he's not dead, but she knows about her. He tries denying it, but she says she wants a divorce. He says he doesn't want one, but ends up leaving. She goes out for a night with her friend, who has since had her baby. They go to enjoy some drinks but the wife runs to the bathroom to vomit. When she comes back, she tries again but once more her stomach refuses to allow her to enjoy her drink. When she goes home she takes a pregnancy test. Then the flashbacks to the induction and delivery occur. In the flashbacks, her husband cries with her as she pushes. She begins telling the baby that it is okay to come out now. She tells him it's his mommy and to come out now. They hand him to her and she holds him in her arms, crying. They spend an hour holding him and taking photos with him as her doctor had recommended. At this point I am bawling uncontrollably they are saying hello and goodbye simultaneously to their son. A nurse comes into the room with a cardboard box and my heart shatters. The nurse puts him in the box like he is a piece of trash and I am filled with immense anger. He was not a piece of trash, he was a baby!
As we could have guessed (and I did) she is pregnant again. She is afraid to let go of her pain, afraid it will mean letting go of her last piece of Arthur. She is also afraid to get too close to her new baby, and her doctor tells her it is completely normal to feel that way. She goes to visit her mom and tell her the news. At first you think the mom is upset. Then her mom tells her everything happens for a reason. At first the wife is upset at this, especially when her mom calls her lucky. Her mom then tells her how she was lucky as well. She had lost a baby due to miscarriage about a year before having her. She said she was lucky because she got pregnant with her. She was her second chance. Her mom tells her how it's not just the loss of a baby they mourn, but the loss of what may have been. She tells her mom she is sorry she lost her baby and her mother tells her that is first time anyone has said that to her. That moment tore my heart in two. Every loss, miscarriage or stillbirth is a loss all the same. It is the loss of a child and as she said what may have been. Every mother deserves for that to be recognized. After telling her mother, she knows she has to tell her husband. So she calls him over and he thinks something must be wrong since they've been apart for a bit now. She tells him that she's pregnant. They say it doesn't change their relationship, but that they will raise the child together. He makes the decision to end the relationship with his coworker and she becomes very angry. He tells her he has to do right by the child and his wife. She then quits her job and joins a competitor.
He wants to read to the baby, like she had with Arthur, but she refuses. She wants this pregnancy to be completely different. He tries to reassure her that nothing will happen again. When they go to a doctor appointment, he hears the heartbeat. He had never been able to hear Arthur's heartbeat since he was working during her appointments. He hears how fast it is and worries something is wrong. The wife and doctor reassure him. That was a cute moment honestly. A typical dad moment. The husband is making a major pitch with his dad during a business meeting. He gets a call from his wife saying she is going into labor. He tells his dad that he has to leave, and his father tells him to wait. He says there will be plenty of time with the baby later. Despite his father yelling at him, he leaves to be with his wife. When the baby is born, it does not cry immediately. The doctor and nurse move to the side to probably clean out it's nostrils. The mom is panicking, asking what's wrong. Then we hear the baby crying. Relief washes over both of them instantly. The doctor tells them it's a girl and tries to hand her to the mom. The mom doesn't reach for her. The husband holds the baby, and hands her to his wife. She doesn't hold him for long. He goes to the nursery with the baby. The wife asks her doctor when she'll feel that bond, that love. Her doctor tells her she will in time. Later the mom is holding the baby and telling her about her big brother that will always be watching over her. At the end of the movie, they go to the beach to release the boat the husband had built when they lost Arthur. Before the credits roll, the movie is dedicated to hundreds of babies that had died. I cried as I read each name.
This movie had so much raw, true emotion in it. My heart shattered for the woman in the film, as if I was truly experiencing her loss. I have never seen a truer portrayal of what a couple goes through when they lose a child. Every emotion, every painful situation, is an accurate description of what I can only imagine one would go through when losing a child. I would recommend this movie to everyone, but I can't. If you have ever lost a child, do not watch it. It will be too close to real for you. I would not want old wounds reopening simply to watch a movie. For everyone else, especially those who know someone who has lost a child, watch this movie please. Please so you can understand why someone changes after they lose their child. Please so you know that sometimes just being there for them, without saying anything is best.